The anti-list
Don't buy this.
Presents that feel thoughtful in the shop and are in a drawer by February.
There is nothing to buy on this page and we earn nothing from it. That is somewhat the point — a site that likes everything is worth nothing, and it is easier to trust the recommendations if you have seen what we think is rubbish.
-
Anything with a slogan on it
World’s Best Dad. Live Laugh Love. A mug that describes the person holding it. These are gifts about the act of giving rather than the person receiving, and everyone involved knows it.
Instead Something they would actually pick up twice. If you cannot think of one, a decent bottle of something is more honest than a printed mug.
-
Novelty socks
The default gift for a man you have run out of ideas for. He owns eleven pairs, wears two, and the rest are a small monument to people not knowing what to get him.
Instead One pair of genuinely good socks costs about the same as five novelty pairs and gets worn until they fall apart.
-
A gadget that solves a problem they do not have
Electric wine openers, egg cookers, banana slicers. The demonstration is delightful, the object lives in a cupboard, and the recipient now has to feel guilty about a cupboard.
Instead Upgrade something they already use daily. The bar is that it replaces an object rather than adding one.
-
Experience vouchers with an expiry date they will miss
A skydive for someone who does not want to skydive is a chore with a deadline. A large proportion are never redeemed, which is a business model rather than a coincidence.
Instead If you are giving an experience, give one they have actually mentioned wanting, and check how long it lasts.
-
Anything that requires them to take up a hobby
A calligraphy set, a sourdough starter kit, a ukulele. This is a gift with homework attached, and it quietly says you would prefer a slightly different person.
Instead Support a hobby they already have. Unglamorous and considerably more likely to be used.
-
Scented candles, unless you know
Scent is intensely personal and the failure mode is a house that smells wrong for a fortnight. Fine as a gift if you have been in their home and noticed what is already there. Otherwise a coin flip.
Instead If in doubt, unscented and well made beats scented and adventurous.
-
Something enormous, for someone in a flat
Storage is a real constraint and a big object obliges them to find room for your feelings. The bigger the box, the more the gift is about the giver.
Instead Small and good. The constraint is the point, and it is a genuinely harder brief.
The general rule
A good present is about the person receiving it. A bad one is about the person giving it — proof of effort, evidence of thoughtfulness, a joke that lands once. The test is whether they would choose it themselves if they happened to see it.